Game week

Michigan Would Not Name Its Two Starting Guards Because Three Seniors Are Going To Split The Job

Jason Beck said on Wednesday that Evan Link, Nathan Efobi and Brady Norton will all play, at fairly similar snap counts, and that the arrangement may run past Saturday. The same afternoon, the defensive coordinator took a similar question and named his starters.

GL
Grant LombardSep 3, 20265 min read
Every call on this site goes on a public ledger and gets graded. The misses stay up.
Evan Link in a tan jacket, white shirt and a navy tie carrying a small maize block M, photographed head-on against white for a Michigan roster portrait.

Michigan's offensive coordinator was asked on Wednesday afternoon who plays guard on Saturday night. He answered with a number.

Three.

Evan Link, Nathan Efobi and Brady Norton will "all play and play fairly similar snaps" at the two guard positions, Jason Beck said, and the staff intends to "let them all play and see where it goes from there." Clayton Sayfie of On3, who has worked this line all through camp, reported that the arrangement may hold for more than one game.

So the answer arrived, and it is not the answer anybody was waiting for. A starting five has been the open question on this offense since the first week of August, when line coach Jim Harding said out loud that he wanted the group solidified by roughly August 22. That date came and went. What Beck said on Wednesday is that two of the five jobs are not going to be assigned to one man each, at least not this week, and possibly not for a while.

Look at the roster and the shape of it makes sense. Michigan lists 118 players. Nineteen of them are listed as OL, with no position attached to a single one. The defense on the same page is broken out to the man: ten ends, nine tackles, eleven cornerbacks, ten safeties. Michigan will tell you which side of the defensive line somebody plays. On the other side of the ball it tells you he is a lineman.

The three guards are three seniors, which is the part that makes the rotation defensible rather than evasive. Link has been the projected left guard most of the summer. Efobi and Norton have been the competition on the right, and Beck said both may take snaps at left guard as well. All three have played college football, and Beck's stated problem is that keeping any one of them off the field is hard.

Everything else up front has a name on it. Blake Frazier is the left tackle, Jake Guarnera is the center, Andrew Sprague is the right tackle. Frazier's job got easier to award when Andrew Babalola, the sophomore who was supposed to push him for it, got hurt again. Beck's own words on that were a hedge, that Babalola had a setback and may not be available for the first week. Sayfie's flat sentence in the same piece is that Babalola will be out for the opener. Both of those are on the record and only one of them is a quotation. Michigan is under no obligation to settle it either way, because the Big Ten's availability reporting covers conference games and Michigan's first conference game is on September 26.

There is a sixth lineman in all this too. Michigan runs a package it calls the rhino, an extra offensive lineman brought on in certain sets, and Norton told Trent Knoop of Wolverine Digest this week who has been taking those snaps. "Mainly the Rhino spot has been Manuel Beigel, who transferred from D-tackle," Norton said. "Avery Gach and Marky Walbridge have also been repping that spot as well." Beigel arrived in Ann Arbor as a defensive tackle. Michigan's roster now lists him at OL.

The defensive coordinator took the same kind of question that afternoon and gave names.

Trey Pierce and Enow Etta, both seniors, "have cemented themselves as the starters on the interior," Zach Edwards wrote at Maize n Brew on Thursday morning, out of Jay Hill's Wednesday availability. Behind them Hill expects Jonah Lea'ea, Bobby Kanka and Deyvid Palepale to play. On the edge it is Dom Nichols and John Henry Daley for the majority of the snaps with Cam Brandt close behind, and then a second group of Nate Marshall, Benny Patterson III and the freshman Tariq Boney. Daley spent the offseason hurt. Hill said Michigan expects him to be full go.

Hill has a depth chart in his head and no apparent difficulty saying it into a microphone. Beck, earlier the same afternoon, would not give two names. The two answers are not a difference in how much each man is willing to say. Hill has starters because his front sorted itself out. Beck does not name two guards because two is not the number he has.

Kalamazoo got its version of this question answered by a surgeon.

Jeremy Schleicher won the Western Michigan center job out of camp last year, got hurt in week three, had season-ending surgery, and worked all offseason to come back. He had a setback over the summer that required another operation and he will miss 2026. So will defensive end Noah Bishop, whose year went the same way, week three of 2025 and then the same summer news. "My heart hurts for those guys," head coach Lance Taylor said on Monday. "So close to returning to play and all that they invested."

The Broncos will start somebody in the middle who has barely played, out of a group Taylor put at "probably six or seven guys that can play for us." That is the ordinary version of an offensive line problem in September, which is not enough bodies, with one more taken away over the summer.

Michigan's problem is the other one. It has three seniors who can play two positions and no reason yet to prefer one of them, so it is going to play all three and find out on the field, in a game, against a team that has been watching four different schools' tape trying to figure out what this offense even looks like.

Somebody will run out at left guard on Saturday night. He will have won the first snap and nothing else, and Beck has already said so, in September, which is not the month college football coaches usually spend telling you what they have not decided yet.

Sources: Jason Beck and Jay Hill press conferences, September 2, 2026, as reported by Clayton Sayfie at On3, Zach Edwards at Maize n Brew and Andrew Graham at Mitten Football; Trent Knoop, Wolverine Digest, September 2, 2026, quoting Brady Norton on the rhino snaps; MGoBlue.com official football roster, read September 3, 2026; Andrew Graham, Mitten Football, August 31 and September 2, 2026, on Western Michigan's offensive line and the Schleicher and Bishop injuries; BigTen.org availability reporting release, August 28, 2026.

Filed under Michigan FB

More on Andrew Babalola

His page →
Penn State allowed six 20-yard runs in a night, and Michigan has one all season
Game day

Penn State allowed six 20-yard runs in a night, and Michigan has one all season

Michigan (3-2, 0-2 Big Ten) hosts Penn State (3-3, 0-3) at Michigan Stadium at 3:30 p.m. Eastern on CBS. DraftKings has Michigan by 6.5 with a total of 42.5 at 8:13 a.m. Eastern, which splits to about Michigan 24.5, Penn State 18. Michigan has one run of 20 yards or more in five games, Bryce Underwood's 38-yard touchdown against Oklahoma; its running backs have 111 carries and a longest of 17. Penn State allowed six runs of 20 or more to Northwestern and none to Wisconsin or USC. Rocco Becht is 59 of 102 for 646 yards in three Big Ten games, 6.3 a throw, after 11.7 against Marshall, Temple and Buffalo. Penn State lists receiver Koby Howard Out; he has 344 receiving yards, all of them in non-conference games. Michigan lists Andrew Sprague and Ace Hamilton Out and Jake Guarnera, Brady Norton, Andrew Babalola, Dom Nichols and John Henry Daley Questionable. Prediction: Michigan 20, Penn State 13.

Wes FerryOct 17, 20265 min read
Three of Michigan's five starting linemen are on the Penn State injury report
Game week

Three of Michigan's five starting linemen are on the Penn State injury report

Michigan's initial Big Ten availability report for Saturday's game against Penn State, filed Wednesday, October 14, lists 14 players, six of them offensive linemen. Jake Guarnera, who started at center at Minnesota, and Brady Norton, another Minnesota starter, are Questionable; Nathan Efobi, a third starter, is Probable. Evan Link and Blake Frazier are not listed. Andrew Sprague is Out, the first time Michigan has opened a week with him at Out rather than Questionable, and Ace Hamilton is Out. Andrew Babalola, Out on all eight of his earlier designations this season, is Questionable. Manuel Beigel, Out on game day at Minnesota, is off the report, which makes him Available under the conference rule. In Michigan's two earlier conference weeks, ten Wednesday Questionable designations ended with three Outs on game day, all three of them offensive linemen; the six non-linemen all finished Available and the fourth lineman, Houston Ka'aha'aina-Torres, was a Game Time Decision who played. One take filed.

Grant LombardOct 15, 20264 min read
Whittingham changed one starter on Monday, and it was the punt returner
Game week

Whittingham changed one starter on Monday, and it was the punt returner

Kyle Whittingham said at his Monday press conference on October 12 that Bryce Underwood remains Michigan's starting quarterback and Jason Beck remains the play-caller for Saturday's game against Penn State. The only personnel change he announced was at punt returner, where Andrew Marsh, who has lost fumbles against Western Michigan and Minnesota, will be replaced for reasons Whittingham said include injury. Right tackle Andrew Sprague, out since the UTEP game, will miss several more weeks; Whittingham said his return is \"way out there.\" Andrew Babalola returned to practice Monday for the first time in about a month, by Whittingham's count. Whittingham said more linemen hurt at Minnesota will be questionable on Wednesday's availability report. Michigan is 3-2 and 0-2 in the Big Ten, its first 0-2 conference start since 2014, with a turnover margin of minus 4; Underwood has thrown 4 interceptions and lost 2 fumbles. Tommy Carr took first-team reps in the bye and could get a series or two. Penn State, 3-3 and 0-3, visits Michigan Stadium at 3:30 p.m. Eastern on October 17.

Grant LombardOct 12, 20264 min read

More on Nathan Efobi

His page →
Michigan's defense scored as many touchdowns as the offense, and Michigan lost
Takeaways

Michigan's defense scored as many touchdowns as the offense, and Michigan lost

Minnesota beat Michigan 20-14 at Huntington Bank Stadium, its first win over Michigan since 2014 and its first in Minneapolis since 1977. Michigan led 14-7 at halftime on Jordan Marshall's 5-yard run and Nathaniel Staehling's 79-yard interception return, then turned the ball over on a muffed punt and two Bryce Underwood interceptions in a span of 7:31. Minnesota scored 13 points off those turnovers on drives of 4, 34 and 35 yards. Michigan's offense gained 180 yards, its fewest of the season, held the ball for 41 seconds of the third quarter, and ran eight plays for no net yards between its touchdown and the fourth quarter. Underwood was 10 of 21 for 101 yards and was sacked three times. The running backs carried 18 times for 59 yards. Michigan's defense forced two turnovers, allowed one scoring drive longer than 35 yards and had no sacks. Michigan's last drive ended with two timeouts unused. JJ Buchanan, Nathan Efobi and Chase Taylor each went down during the game, and Kyle Whittingham said a couple of players could not finish without naming them. Michigan is 3-2 and 0-2 in the Big Ten.

Wes FerryOct 4, 20266 min read
Michigan Has Played Eight Of The Nineteen Offensive Linemen On Its Roster
The line

Michigan Has Played Eight Of The Nineteen Offensive Linemen On Its Roster

Michigan beat eleventh-ranked Oklahoma 17-10 on September 12 with an offensive line that its own Player Participation release lists one deep at every position. Evan Link, the opening-day left guard, is not on that document anywhere, and nobody said why until Kyle Whittingham's Monday press conference, where he said the staff shuffled the lineup due to injury and nothing else. Link should return this week and may share left guard with Nathan Efobi. Andrew Babalola, a five-star who has still never played a college snap, had a setback and will not be available in the near future. Michigan lists nineteen offensive linemen. Eight have taken an offensive snap.

Grant LombardSep 15, 20265 min read

On the record

Called Shots →
Held upAug 11, 2026

Michigan has not publicly identified all five offensive line starters by name and position on or before August 22, 2026.

Harding's target was internal solidification rather than an announcement, and that gap is the whole basis of the call: programs settle a line in the building weeks before they say so, and Michigan has published no depth chart. There are three spots open, one of them left tackle, where Kyle Whittingham said on Monday that Andrew Babalola, Evan Link and Blake Frazier are splitting the majority of the reps, and Babalola did not play in 2025. Whittingham's own marker is looser than a date: about 10 practices before definitive decisions, and five were in the bank on Monday. It fails if coaches or the program name all five spots on or before August 22, including a released depth chart or a coach confirming the five in an availability. Reporters projecting a five does not resolve it, because the claim is about what Michigan says rather than what anyone predicts. A partial naming, four of five, does not resolve it either.

Latest on the Michigan FB

The whole beat →
Michigan's last three opponents are 21-6, and each is playing for the playoff
The wider view

Michigan's last three opponents are 21-6, and each is playing for the playoff

The College Football Playoff selection committee's second ranking, released November 10, has UCLA 4th, Oregon 16th and Ohio State 20th, Michigan's last three opponents, who are a combined 21-6. Michigan, 5-4 and unranked, needs one win for bowl eligibility. By DraftKings' moneylines with the margin removed, it has about a 22% chance at Oregon and 18% at Ohio State.

Wes FerryNov 11, 20265 min read
Twelve throws on third-and-short, three sacks: what Jim Harding inherits
Deep dive

Twelve throws on third-and-short, three sacks: what Jim Harding inherits

By CollegeFootballData's play-by-play across Michigan's nine 2026 games, Michigan converted 17 of 27 third downs with 3 yards or fewer to go when it ran and 5 of 12 when it threw, with three sacks on those throws, all against Indiana. Tommy Carr has been sacked on about 1 dropback in 9, against 1 in 19 for Bryce Underwood, and its first- and second-down runs have lost ground more often. Jim Harding, the offensive line coach, is now interim coordinator and will lead a collaborative play-calling group at Oregon, which has at least two sacks in each of its last six games.

Wes FerryNov 9, 20266 min read
Michigan held Michigan State without a touchdown and lost by nine
Takeaways

Michigan held Michigan State without a touchdown and lost by nine

Michigan State beat Michigan 15-6 at Michigan Stadium on November 7 on five Liam Boyd field goals. Twelve of the 15 points came on drives that started at the Michigan State 38 or better, set up by two Michigan punts from deep after sacks and by two turnovers. Michigan gained 192 yards, was sacked five times, went 2 of 10 on third down and did not score until 1:35 remained.

Wes FerryNov 8, 20266 min read

Earlier on the Michigan FB

Is Bryce Underwood a better passer, or did he play Western Michigan and UTEP?
Like for like

Is Bryce Underwood a better passer, or did he play Western Michigan and UTEP?

Bryce Underwood's 2026 passing line looks better than his freshman line: 50.0 percent of his dropbacks have been successful plays against 41.4 percent in 2025, and his expected points added per dropback has risen from +0.14 to +0.31. By expected points, the schedule explains all of that; by success rate, somewhere between a sixth of it and nearly all of it. Forty-nine of his 68 dropbacks this season came against Western Michigan and UTEP, against 58 of 355 against Group of Five teams in 2025. Against Group of Five opponents he completed 66.1 percent in 2025 and 66.0 percent this season. Against Oklahoma, the one Power 4 defence in both seasons, his success rate went from 20.0 percent to 31.6 percent and his expected points from -0.05 to -0.02. Reweighting his 2025 rates to this season's schedule puts his matched expected points at +0.38 or +0.33, both above his actual +0.31; the matched success-rate gain is between 0.4 and 7.2 points, inside the sampling error of 68 plays. Michigan is not throwing less by choice: on first and second down in one-score games through three quarters it has passed on 44.2 percent of plays, against 44.4 percent in 2025. Iowa's pass defence ranked 13th of 136 last season by expected points allowed per pass play; Oklahoma's was 17th. One take filed, on yards per attempt in Big Ten games.

Jamie SilvaSep 23, 20268 min read
Michigan drew five of the Big Ten's other ranked teams. Penn State drew two.
The wider view

Michigan drew five of the Big Ten's other ranked teams. Penn State drew two.

Michigan is 3-0 and 18th in the AP poll with 432 points, sixth of the seven Big Ten teams in the Top 25. Oklahoma, the 11th-ranked team Michigan beat on September 12, beat New Mexico 14-6 on Saturday and dropped out of the AP poll; it is 24th in the coaches poll. Michigan's nine Big Ten games include five of the six other ranked conference teams, everyone but USC, and those five hold 4,657 AP points, the most on any ranked Big Ten team's schedule. Penn State's two ranked conference opponents hold 1,339 and Iowa's hold 1,847. Of the five unbeaten Big Ten teams in the AP poll, Michigan is the only one ranked lower than in the preseason ballot. Indiana and Penn State have not played a team from the ACC, Big Ten, Big 12 or SEC. The 12-team playoff takes the champions of those four conferences, the highest-ranked champion from six other conferences, and the next seven highest-ranked teams. The committee publishes six rankings, the first on November 3 and the last on Selection Day, December 6. The Big Ten championship game is December 5 in Indianapolis between the top two teams in the conference standings. Michigan hosts Iowa on Saturday at 3:30 p.m. Eastern on CBS.

Wes FerrySep 23, 20266 min read
Michigan Lost Four Of Five Third-And-Shorts To A Team Averaging 3.3 Yards A Play
Deep dive

Michigan Lost Four Of Five Third-And-Shorts To A Team Averaging 3.3 Yards A Play

Michigan beat Western Michigan 13-12 and the possession number that defined the night has a narrow cause. Across 18 third downs the Broncos converted eight. On the 13 that needed four yards or more, Michigan allowed four. On the five that needed three or fewer, Western Michigan ran the ball every time and converted four, twice on quarterback keepers up the middle out of shotgun on third-and-1. Michigan's own offense was the more efficient one, 276 yards on 48 snaps against 221 on 67, and it lined up under center exactly four times all night, consecutively, from first-and-goal at the 5 through the fourth-and-goal touchdown that opened the scoring. It never went back, and it won the game on the last snap of the night. The three-turnover total the box score carries includes a muffed punt that no offensive drive chart records.

Wes FerrySep 7, 20267 min read